Skip to main content

Not a Fan

 


“Football is for everyone!”

These words begin an announcement from County Executive Calvin Ball yesterday about a new girls’ Flag Football initiative in the Howard County Schools. The program will receive financial support from the Baltimore Ravens and Under Armour. An investment in girls’ sports is worth celebrating, especially right now.


Image from County Executive Ball’s social media


In case people wonder if I ever disagree with our esteemed County Executive, well…

No, I don’t think football is for everyone. American tackle football is dangerous and violent and continues to chew up and spit out athletes whose futures are marred by permanent injuries both to body and brain. The world of professional football is steeped in systemic racism where the abilities and dedication of Black players are exploited to create financial benefit for the entire network of white people who hold power. 

High school football is certainly not for marching bands who are often told they may not practice their routines on the field because they might somehow spoil it for the football players. Or other high school programs that languish while big money pours in to support football. 

But we keep saying this thing anyway, that football is for everyone. Why? 

Professor emeritus of sociology and gender studies at USC , Michael Messner, sums it up nicely. In an Op Ed for the LA Times, he writes:

High school football, and its accompanying spirit rituals, remains a key nexus of group pleasure and collective identity.*

I love the very academic tone here, the way his assessment is rooted in sociological observation and study. Oh, those primitive peoples, performing their spirit rituals to affirm collective identity.

I think we have now safely established that I take a dim view of “football is for everyone.” 

My opinion is not going to cause anyone any lasting harm and you are not obliged to agree with me. If you’ve been here a while you know I’ve written about this before, in particular, high school tackle football.

Maybe It’s Time to Talk, August, 2017

The Good Old Days, February, 2018

But you don’t have to take my word for it.

Key Characteristics: Football has the highest injury and concussion rates among all sports, regardless of gender, according to the National High School Sports-Related Injury Surveillance Study. Injuries to the head/face, ankle, knee and hand/wrist are the most common. Though still low relatively speaking, football’s catastrophic rate is more than twice as high as the next-closest boys sport (lacrosse).

- - The Healthy Sports Index, Hospital for Special Surgery (learn more here)

Now it appears that the risk of brain trauma may also affect much younger athletes. According to a new study in JAMA Network Open, high-school football players can show alterations in brain tissue too. While it’s impossible to determine the presence of CTE without conducting an autopsy of the brain, the work provided disturbing evidence that playing the game early in life may lead to serious problems later on.

- - Football Can Damage the Brains of High-School Players, Jeffrey Kluger, Time

And, coming back to Messner in the LA Times:

Sometimes, when we think about gender equity we ask the wrong questions, based on the assumption that equity means girls and women striving to do what boys and men have been doing for decades. In this case, instead of asking why girls don’t play tackle football, more people are starting to ask why boys do, while suggesting that it may be time to start moving boys — starting with youth sports and extending into middle school and high school — into flag football.

 - - If tackle football isn’t safe for girls, why do we let boys play? , Michael A. Messner, LA Times Voices

That’s a very good question. If tackle football isn’t safe for girls, why do we let boys play? Why, indeed? I think I know why. Far too many people are emotionally invested in this almost sanctified world of high school football. They must reenact those all-important spirit rituals and bask in the nexus of group pleasure and collective identity.

If we continue to sacrifice young men on this cultural altar we are a very primitive people, in my opinion. 


Village Green/Town² Comments


*In the same way, we might also say that professional football, “…and its accompanying spirit rituals, remains a key nexus of group pleasure and collective identity.”



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Getting Fresh

One of my favorite days in the Spring comes when this year’s list of Farmer’s Markets is released. That happened this week. New this year are markets in Old Ellicott City and the “Merriweather Market” which, according to the address, will be located here . I mistakenly thought at first glance that it was in the new-construction part of the Merriweather District. I find the name confusing considering its actual location. I’m going to guess that this market is an initiative of the Howard Hughes Corporation because the name seems chosen more for branding purposes than anything else.  Alas, the market in Maple Lawn is gone. The thread on the markets on the County Executive’s FB page will provide you with quite the education in who actually runs the Farmers Markets vs what people often think is going on. Short answer: they are not  chosen nor run by the county. Each market is an independent entity, sometimes started by community volunteers, other times supported by local businesses...
1 comment
Read more

Teacher Gifts

Today is the last day of school before the Winter Break. It’s a good time to remember the far-reaching nature of our public school system. You may not have children. You may have sent your children to independent schools. It matters not. You will be impacted one way or another. Yesterday I read a long thread on Facebook about several waves of illness in the schools right now. There’s influenza A and norovirus, I believe. And of course there’s COVID. Apparently in some individual schools the rate of illness is high enough for school admin to notify parents.  When I was little the acceptable holiday gift for a teacher was one of those lovely floral handkerchief squares. (I don’t know what it was for male teachers. They were rare in my elementary years.) These days the range of teacher gifts is wider and I have fond memories of Target gift cards which I have written about before. I think it’s safe to say that giving one’s teacher Influenza, norovirus, or COVID is not the ideal holiday...
1 comment
Read more

They Can Wait

This is not a typical Saturday post. That’s because, in my community, it’s not a typical Saturday.  Oakland Mills High School, after years of deferred repair, needs massive renovation. It’s pretty simple: when you don’t fix a problem it gets bigger. The school system itself said the the OMHS school building was  "no longer conducive to learning" back in 2018.  2018 .  But Thursday the Boad of Education voted to push it out of the lineup of important projects which will be given the go-ahead to proceed soonest.  In my opinion it’s a terrible decision and sets a dangerous precedent. To explain, here’s the advocacy letter I sent in support of Oakland Mills High School. I was rather proud of it. I am writing to ask you to proceed with needed renovation at Oakland Mills High School in the most timely and comprehensive manner humanly possible. I have read the letter sent to you by the Oakland Mills Community Association and I am in complete agreement. You are extremel...
1 comment
Read more